Posted on December 3, 2012 with 1,830 notes.
Tagged with Scissor Sisters, Let's Have A Kiki, Black Gay Culture, Latino Gay Culture, Vogue, cultural appropriation, .

I knew “Kiki” was by the Scissor Sisters, a band I really like, and I was excited they turned to black gay culture for creative inspiration. Watch the music video, though, and you don’t see a single person of color. Anywhere. I mean, how can you do a music video about serving, working and letting them have it and not show some fierce bitch from the blatino gay scene! Even the opening monologue of the song, where lead Scissor Sister Ana Matronic sasses off about how her party was ruined and now her weave is messed up, is said in an inflected black voice. Why didn’t they just get a cameo from somebody from the vogue scene?

This is not like when Lena Dunham didn’t cast any brown folks on Girls. That was about not thinking about brown people period. This is about stealing from brown people and not thinking about them, period. In the case of “Kiki,” queer brown folks are the ones who invented the terms that make up the entirety of the Scissor Sisters chart-topping song, and those faces have been completely wiped out. I’m willing to bet that the gays watching this video will have no idea where these words come from. But the reality is that these are terms that were created so that gays of color could communicate with one another in a clandestine way, and scholars like E. Patrick Johnson, Henry Louis Gates, and Geneva Smitherman have done research on the uniqueness and specificity of black (gay) speech patterns. For the Scissor Sisters to use and capitalize on black gay slang without paying due credit to the people who invented it isn’t appropriation—it’s straight up cultural larceny.
  1. diamondsxstags reblogged this from irresistible-revolution
  2. filthyshowtunes reblogged this from feministcharacters
  3. poparoll reblogged this from anotherfeminist
  4. priestessthief reblogged this from obscenepromqueen
  5. samwilhelm reblogged this from jakegyllenhaalelujah
  6. jakegyllenhaalelujah reblogged this from nokiabae
  7. nokiabae reblogged this from secretandroid
  8. polarink reblogged this from tearingdownthatfence
  9. tearingdownthatfence reblogged this from bifury
  10. rickjamesbitch reblogged this from blooming-white-tea
  11. blooming-white-tea reblogged this from obscenepromqueen
  12. hottrike reblogged this from bifury
  13. thejoyofq reblogged this from obscenepromqueen
  14. obscenepromqueen reblogged this from grasstomyknees
  15. emological reblogged this from quirkyblackgirls
  16. lesbeards reblogged this from penis-hunger-games
  17. penis-hunger-games reblogged this from grasstomyknees
  18. grasstomyknees reblogged this from fonnatasha
  19. fonnatasha reblogged this from queerandpresentdanger